Brand and AI

Your Team Can Write Its Brand Strategy Without an Agency

A team that studies its competitors' promises first can keep the strategy in-house and pay outsiders to make things and check the work.

By Ines Calloway · November 20, 2026 · 6 min read

A paper sewing pattern pinned flat on fabric, marked with chalk lines and held by pins.
The pattern gets drawn inside the business, and outside hands can still cut and sew from it.

A company can build its brand strategy without an agency if it reads its market on purpose before writing a word about itself. Keep the thinking inside the business. Outsiders are worth paying for two jobs: making what the strategy calls for, and testing the strategy itself.

The case for an agency is a fair one. An agency brings an outside view, and a team that has repeated its own pitch for years stops noticing which parts of it every competitor also says.

Much of that outside view, though, is a reading of the market: what every competitor promises, and the assumptions a buyer walks in with. A team can do that reading itself, and it's the first step of DIY brand strategy.

A holiday park operator ran its rebrand from the inside

Pete Chapman, CMO of Reflections Holidays, described one way to split the work in an article the Australian Marketing Institute republished in March 2024. Reflections is an Australian consumer business, and the quotes are Chapman's account at launch, before any results were in. He also spent 20 years in agencies first, experience a typical do-it-yourself team won't have.

Reflections is a profit-for-purpose operator with 37 holiday parks and 43 community reserves on Crown land in New South Wales. It relaunched as Reflections Holidays on March 18, 2024, after 12 months of planning.

Chapman's team worked out the brand idea and the strategy inside the business. He hired an in-house art director, Matt Plummer, and still used outside partners for creative help, social media and execution.

Reading every rival's promise is the agency advantage a team can copy

Before you draft anything about your own brand, collect the headline promise from each competitor and write down what a buyer already assumes about your market.

Chapman found them in his old brand, which was "framing it up as a holiday park, bringing all the stereotypes of the category with it – good, bad and indifferent."

An outsider spots stereotypes like that because they haven't absorbed them yet. An insider has to go looking, and has to decide to look before writing the strategy.

For a fuller method, the guide to reading a competitive messaging audit walks through competitors' copy.

The difference worth building sits in what your market won't say

With the promises side by side, write one phrase that covers what the whole market says. Then list what your customers value that none of those promises mention.

A tied stack of identical brochures next to a single canvas-covered notebook.
With every rival's brochure in one pile, the promise they all share is hard to miss.

Chapman's version fills in both halves: "The holiday park category is about fun and amusement. And we're not – we're about connection, nature, getting outside, adventure."

His first sentence is the market's phrase. His second is the list, and Reflections built its new brand on it.

The phrase for the market should be blunt enough that every competitor would recognize it as their own. The list should come from what your customers value.

Finding that gap when every competitor sounds alike has its own guide to category white space.

A new brand has to wait for the business to change

Chapman held the relaunch until the parks were different. Reflections had "thrown out the man-made waterslides and jumping pillows" first.

A deflated inflatable play cushion, rolled and strapped with webbing onto a flatbed trailer.
A jumping pillow, the kind Reflections Holidays cleared out before its relaunch.

His reasoning: "to throw a grenade like a rebrand in before we'd proven to the world we were different would have been a real mistake."

For a team working alone, ask whether a customer who turned up tomorrow would find what the new strategy promises. If they wouldn't, change the business before you change the brand.

Whether a repositioning is the right move at all is covered in the guide on when to reposition a brand.

One person inside should own the strategy, and the making can be bought

Chapman treated the in-house vs agency brand strategy question as two choices: "let's do the thinking internally, get a few really good people set-up internally, then we'll partner on the stuff that needs to get made."

Chapman gave each of them one job: "I looked after strategy; Matt was on creative."

One owner matters because someone has to decide what the brand says and turn down what doesn't fit. Name that person before the work starts. They write the market's phrase and the list of what it leaves out, and outside partners make things from that written strategy.

If your team plans to use AI tools for parts of the thinking, the guide to AI and brand strategy covers it.

The outsiders who won were solving problems the firms wrote down

The strongest case for handing over the strategy comes from research on outside problem-solvers.

Lars Bo Jeppesen and Karim Lakhani studied 166 science problems posted to outside solvers. A winning solution was "positively related to increasing distance between the solver's field of technical expertise and the focal field of the problem." The effect clears only a loose statistical bar and comes from science problems, so read it as a direction.

The problems came from the R&D labs of 26 firms in 10 countries, and more than 12,000 scientists took part. The firms judged 49 of the 166 solved, a rate of 29.5%.

Read quickly, that argues for handing the strategy to an outsider. Look at how the problems reached the solvers, though. Each one was written down in a company's own lab and sent out, so the firms did the defining before any outsider saw it.

Chapman's split follows that order: the strategy stayed inside the business, and outsiders came in afterwards to check it.

Outside eyes earn their fee by attacking a written draft

"Then we collaborated with great talent outside the business to keep the process honest," Chapman said. His team "made each element fight for why it'd stay in."

For a team without Chapman's 20 agency years, this is the step to spend on. Write the strategy down. Give it to people who don't work in the business and ask them where it sounds like every competitor, and where the business can't back it up.

Keep a line only if its owner can say why it stays.

If you'd like to talk through which parts of your brand strategy to keep inside and what that means for your brand, get in touch.

Reflections spent 12 months planning before the new brand went live.

Frequently asked questions

Can a company build a brand strategy without an agency?
Yes, if it reads its market on purpose before writing about itself, collecting each competitor's headline promise and what buyers already assume. One person inside the business owns the strategy, and outsiders are paid to make what it calls for and to test the written draft.
What does DIY brand strategy start with?
It starts with competitors, before any writing about your own brand. Collect each competitor's headline promise, write one phrase that covers what the whole market says, then list what your customers value that none of those promises mention.
Should brand strategy be done in-house or by an agency?
The work can be split. One person inside owns the strategy and decides what the brand says, and outside partners make what it calls for. Reflections Holidays' CMO, Pete Chapman, described doing "the thinking internally" and partnering "on the stuff that needs to get made."
When is outside help still worth paying for in brand strategy?
Outside help pays for making things and for testing the strategy. Give the written draft to people who don't work in the business and ask where it sounds like every competitor and where the business can't back it up.
Should you relaunch your brand as soon as the strategy is written?
Wait until the business matches what the strategy promises. Reflections Holidays removed its man-made waterslides and jumping pillows before relaunching, and Chapman said a rebrand before proving the difference "would have been a real mistake."

Sources

Share this article

LinkedIn X